The WTO dispute settlement system and its operation: A brief overview of the first ten years

The WTO dispute settlement system plays a central role in clarifying and enforcing the legal obligations contained in the various WTO agreements. It is generally agreed among WTO Members that the WTO dispute settlement system has functioned reasonably well in its first ten years, although the jurisprudence emanating from this system has not been without its critics from both the public and private sectors of a large cross-section of the WTO membership. The purpose of this chapter, however, is not to analyse or comment on the jurisprudence that the system has produced; such analysis and commentary must be left to the Members themselves and to legal scholars and commentators. Rather, the purpose of this chapter is to provide a brief overview of the system and how it has operated in the first ten years of its existence (1995–2004), including the extent to which the system has been used by Members; the nature of the cases brought to the system; and Members’ compliance record with respect to adverse panel and Appellate Body reports.